After coaching you on how to create fantastic brows like a pro makeup artist, we know you’re ready to up your game. But as much as pencils and powders let you create face-framing arches, sometimes, these products can leave your brows looking too drawn on and flat on your face.

Enter your new kilay BFF: brow mascaras—a great finishing product to use right after shaping and filling your eyebrows in with pencil or powder. These babies coat and tint brow hair, tame unruly strands, and create the illusion of lush, even 3D-looking, face framers. The result: eyebrows as full and thick as Cara Delevingne’s and Lily Collins’. Ready to wiggle these wands on your arches? Keep on clicking our gallery to see our top picks.

(Image edited by Mike Dee; Photo courtesy of Cara Delevingne's Instagram account)